Strategic Claims Counsel, Vendor Strategy & Legal Operations We offer a hybrid work setting that offers flexibility to our employees in balancing in-office (2 days per week OR 15 hours per week in a Wawanesa office) and work from home.Working Business Language : English In addition to salary, full-time and part-time permanent employees are eligible for an annual bonus plan, leave of absence top-up programs and provided with generous vacation time, personal days, premium free benefits and pension plan. The salary offered for this role is determined with consideration to various factors, including but not limited to: your work location, local labour market conditions, external market salary data, internal pay equity and the knowledge, skills, experience and anticipated proficiency in the role.

About The Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Company

Founded in 1896, The Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Company is one of Canada’s largest mutual insurers, 100% owned by its members, with more than $4.1 billion in annual revenue and $12.5 billion in assets. Headquartered in Winnipeg, Wawanesa is the parent company of Wawanesa Life, which provides life insurance solutions throughout Canada, and Western Financial Group, a leading national distributor of personal and business insurance. In March of 2026, Wawanesa entered into an agreement to acquire Everest Insurance Company of Canada to strengthen its commercial insurance capabilities and advance its long-term growth strategy.

The company actively gives back to organizations that strengthen communities, donating more than $4 million annually to charitable organizations, including more than $2 million each year in support of people on the front lines of climate change. This role is responsible for establishing and leading the enterprise framework for external counsel governance, performance management, and legal spend oversight. Leveraging insurance litigation expertise, vendor governance, and data-driven insights, the role drives the quality, consistency, and value of legal services while ensuring alignment between external counsel performance,



claims strategies, and business objectives.

As the organization's lead for external counsel management, the role provides strategic oversight of panel counsel relationships, performance standards, legal spend management, and vendor governance practices, supporting effective stewardship of external legal resources and improved claims outcomes across the enterprise. Lead the design and implementation of a structured external counsel performance management program, including governance frameworks, processes, tools, and reporting. Develop and maintain a claims-wide panel counsel strategy, including firm selection, specialization, and geographic alignment.

Support vendor selection and onboarding processes, including participation in RFPs and evaluation of external law firms. Ensure alignment between vendor services and claims strategies and business priorities. Design and implement a structured performance management framework, including defined KPIs and service expectations.

Lead ongoing reviews of law firm performance using quantitative and qualitative data. Conduct file-level reviews and audits to assess quality and alignment with internal claims strategies. Analyze litigation performance and identify opportunities to improve outcomes, consistency, and service quality.

Partner with Claims and Finance to establish and support legal spend management practices, including cost tracking, reporting, and budgeting insights. Establish and oversee billing guidelines and invoice review processes, ensuring compliance and cost discipline. Develop and maintain performance dashboards and reporting to support informed decision-making regarding firm selection, file assignment,



and continued engagement.

Translate litigation, spend, and performance data into actionable insights that inform vendor strategy and program improvements. Serve as a key point of contact for external law firms, supporting effective and collaborative vendor relationships. Law degree and membership in good standing with a Canadian law society (preferred), or a combination of related education and experience. ~7+ years of litigation experience, preferably within insurance defence, bodily injury, casualty, or complex claims litigation. ~ Demonstrated expertise in external counsel management, vendor governance, legal operations, or related legal service delivery models. ~ Experience establishing performance measures, evaluating service delivery, and leveraging data and insights to drive business decisions and continuous improvement. ~ Experience reviewing, supervising, auditing, or managing external law firms or qualified service providers. ~ Strong analytical and financial acumen, including experience interpreting legal spend, performance metrics, and outcome data. ~ Ability to collaborate effectively across Claims, Finance, Procurement, Vendor Management, and other cross-functional teams. ~ Diversity Equity, Inclusion & Belonging At Wawanesa, we are committed to Diversity, Equity, Inclusion and Belonging (DEIB) and believe that our strength lies in the diversity of our people – this is supported by having a representative workforce.

We welcome applications from all qualified candidates, including racialized persons, women, Indigenous Peoples, persons with disabilities, members of the 2SLGBTQIA+ community, gender-diverse and neurodiverse individuals, and anyone who can contribute to the further diversification of thought and ideas. If you require accommodations during any stage of the recruitment process, please reach out in confidence to [email protected] final decisions are taken or reviewed by human recruiters and human hiring leaders in compliance with all applicable legislation. #

📌 Strategic Claims Counsel, Vendor Strategy & Legal Operations (Toronto)
🏢 Wawanesa
📍 Toronto