Pizza Maker Supervisor – Evening Shifts

Liberty Pizzeria – Toronto, ON

Pay: $18.5–$22 per hour

Job Type: Full-time

Schedule: Evening and closing shifts, including weekends

Liberty Pizzeria is looking for an experienced Pizza Maker Supervisor to lead our team and oversee store operations during evening shifts. This is a hands-on leadership position for someone who can confidently make pizzas, manage a team, and keep the location running smoothly.

Responsibilities:

- Stretch, top, and bake New York–style pizzas
- Lead and supervise the team during evening and closing shifts
- Assign tasks and manage workflow during service
- Maintain consistency in recipes, portions, presentation, and cooking.
- Monitor service speed, order accuracy, and customer experience
- Train, coach, and support new and existing employees
- Assist with staff scheduling and shift coverage when needed
- Organize prep and ensure sufficient ingredients are available.
- Monitor inventory and communicate ordering and production needs
- Control food waste, portions, and labor efficiency
- Maintain food safety, cleanliness, FIFO, and equipment standards
- Supervise closing procedures and ensure the store is properly secured.
- Handle customer concerns professionally and promptly
- Monitor cash-handling and end-of-day procedures
- Communicate with the production team and company leadership
- Report staffing, inventory, maintenance,



sales, and operational issues
- Help the location achieve its sales, labor, service, and customer-review goals

Requirements:

- Previous professional pizza-making experience is required.
- Previous supervisory or restaurant-management experience is required.
- Strong leadership, communication, and organizational skills
- Comfortable working in a fast-paced, high-volume kitchen
- Able to train employees and hold the team accountable
- Reliable, punctual, responsible, and solutions-oriented
- Solid attention to quality, consistency, and operational details
- Must be available for evening and closing shifts
- Weekend and holiday availability is required.
- Food Handler Certification is preferred.

At Liberty Pizzeria, we serve hand-stretched New York–style pizza made fresh with quality ingredients and no seed oils. We’re looking for someone who leads by example, takes ownership of their shift, and wants to grow with our company.

To apply:

Please submit your résumé and a short introduction describing your pizza-making, supervisory, and restaurant-management experience.

Job Types: Full-time, Part-time, Permanent

Pay: $18.00-$22.00 per hour

Experience

- Pizza Cook: 1 year (required)

Licence/Certification:
- Food Handler Certification (preferred)

Work Location: In person

📌 Pizza Maker Supervisor – Evening Shifts (Toronto)
🏢 Liberty Pizzeria
📍 Toronto